Aquarius and Pisces Compatibility: A Mismatch That Could Work

On paper, this quirky duo doesn't look like they'd be that great together. But they have a lot going for them.

Published March 21, 2024
Happy couple in love cuddling

Have you ever met a couple who seem totally mismatched but somehow just work? It could be an Aquarius and Pisces pairing. While on paper, Aquarius and Pisces seem pretty incompatible, sometimes this pairing can work. And if it does, it's usually because the two have managed to focus on their friendship as the most important aspect of their romantic relationship.

How Aquarius & Pisces Are Alike and Different

At first glance, it may seem that Pisces and Aquarius are quite different. One is intellectually driven, while the other lives firmly in the emotional realm. But when you dig a little deeper, there are enough similarities that could make for a compatible romantic relationship.

Pisces & Aquarius Similarities

Young Couple Laughing On A Winter Beach

Pisces is mutable water. Aquarius is fixed air. So it may be difficult to imagine how these two signs could have any similarities at all. But there are a few places where Pisces and Aquarius have a meeting of the minds, which can bode well in romantic compatibility

  • They're both extremely creative souls.
  • They're both idealistic and humanitarian.
  • They're both free-spirited.
  • They're both friendly.
  • They each hold a unique worldview.
  • They're both adaptable.

Related: Aquarius Compatibility & Best Matches for Love

Aquarius & Pisces Differences

It probably comes as no surprise that Pisces and Aries have significant differences between them that can lead to some fundamental incompatibilities in a relationship.

  • Pisces goes with the flow and is easily changeable. And while for a fixed sign, Aquarius is also adaptable, when they're entrenched in a value or ideal, they can be extremely stubborn. 
  • As an air sign, Aquarius is intellectually driven. As a water sign, Pisces is emotionally driven. They have fundamentally different approaches to life.
  • Aquarius can be aloof, and they need a lot of space in relationships. Pisces is deeply romantic and longs for a merging of souls in relationships.
  • Aquarius may see Pisces as being over-the-top dramatic, while Pisces may see Aquarius as closed off and distant.

Related: Pisces Compatibility & Best Matches for Love

Aquarius & Pisces Compatibility: The Odd Couple

Pisces and Aquarius make great friends. But when it comes to romantic relationships, they could struggle with the disconnect between head-centered (Aquarius) and heart-centered (Pisces) living. They have significant challenges to overcome, but this is far from an impossible match.

Relationship Aspect Rating
Emotional connection Fair
Trust Fair
Sexual connection Good
Intellectual connection Very good
Communication Fair
Values compatibility Very good

Pisces's and Aquarius's Emotional Connection

Pisces flits through emotions quickly and longs for that soulmate kind of connection with their partner. Aquarius holds emotions at arm's-length and instead prefers to lead with logic. Pisces is intuitive. Aquarius is cerebral. So these two can connect emotionally. But in romantic relationships with such fundamentally different ways of inhabiting their lives, for it to be a satisfying emotional connection for both of them, there will be some challenges.

Rating: Fair

Trust Between Pisces & Aquarius

Pisces wants a partner who will idealize them and hold them as precious. Aquarius tends to hold others at arm's length, needing a lot of personal space and expecting their partner to be just as independent as they are. Naturally, these contrasting needs can lead to some trust issues. They can be overcome with good communication, but it will take mutual effort.

Rating: Fair

Pisces & Aquarius Sexually

When two open-minded people head to the bedroom, sex can be a lot of fun. And so it can be for Pisces and Aquarius, who both like to try new things. Add the pair's creativity, and you can certainly see why they might tear it up in the sheets. On the other hand, Pisces approaches sex for emotional connection and nothing less than a melding of souls, while for Aquarius, sex is more of an intellectual pursuit. So while they may come at it from different angles and have different goals in the bedroom, sex between an Aquarius and a Pisces can be a good time.

Rating: Good

Intellectual Compatibility Between Aquarius & Pisces

This is a pairing of two extremely open-minded individuals, which can lead to some great philosophical conversations. While each has a different approach to their thought process, they find each other interesting and often of like minds. This can be a good intellectual match.

Rating: Very Good

Communication Between Pisces & Aquarius

A couple of men looking at the camera while embracing

These two speak different languages. Pisces speaks the language of the heart. Aquarius is very much in their head. This can lead to some difficulties in communication between the two unless they can find a way to bridge the gap in how they think about, process, and share information. 

Rating: Fair

Aquarius's & Pisces's Values Compatibility

Both Aquarius and Pisces have a humanitarian outlook on life, so their values tend to align quite well. When philosophical differences do arise, each partner is flexible and open-minded enough to hear the other out and possibly agree to disagree instead of turning it into a battle of wills. This is one of this couple's greatest strengths.

Rating: Very Good

Best of Friends and Possibly More

If they're looking for a BFF, Aquarius and Pisces make a great pair. And friendship can be the foundation for a strong romantic relationship as well. While an Aquarius and Pisces pairing can face a lot of challenges, with two open-minded and creative people involved, it could just be a great love match. 

Trending on LoveToKnow
Aquarius and Pisces Compatibility: A Mismatch That Could Work